The Student Journal of Business & Economics

Explaining the Singapore-Malaysia Divergence: The New Economic Policy And Ethnic Chinese Occupational Attainment In Malaysia

Loy, Xing Hao

doi: 10.67521/sjbe.2026.042

Abstract

Despite a shared British common-law system, geography, culture and colonial background, Singapore's and Malaysia's economies diverged from the 1970s onwards. As they shared largely similar contracting institutions, this paper investigates whether property rights institutions can help explain this split. While existing literature examines the New Economic Policy (NEP) and Industrial Co-ordination Act (ICA) mainly as ethnic redistribution policies, this paper analyses them as a property rights institution shock under the institutions framework. The ICA enforced the NEP's 30 per cent Bumiputera (Malays and other indigenous groups) equity target and ethnic restructuring of managerial and professional employment through manufacturing licence conditions. Current studies also examine the NEP within Malaysia in isolation. This paper uses a difference-in-differences design with Singapore serving as a counterfactual to compare the share of the ethnic Chinese workforce in professional, managerial, administrative and technical (PMAT) occupations. From 1970 to 1990, Malaysian Chinese PMAT share grew 11.1 percentage points less than in Singapore. This gap is consistent with the NEP/ICA slowing Chinese occupational growth, assuming the parallel trends assumption holds. A robustness check on Malay workers gives the opposite sign (+1.8), consistent with an ethnically targeted policy. A triple difference using economy-wide occupational data tests for the presence of "Ali Baba" arrangements, which are associated with extractive institutions. Its evidence on such arrangements is mixed, but the Chinese share grew more slowly than in Singapore in both occupational tiers, suggesting the slower growth was not only due to nominal title transfers from Ali Baba arrangements.

Read full paper (PDF)

Cite (Chicago)

Loy, Xing Hao. “Explaining the Singapore-Malaysia Divergence: The New Economic Policy And Ethnic Chinese Occupational Attainment In Malaysia.” Student Journal of Business and Economics (2026). https://doi.org/10.67521/sjbe.2026.042.

All papers